Top Unsettling Mystery Reviews

Demon's Souls - PlayStation 5

  • Discover where the journey began - Experience the original brutal challenge, completely remade from the ground up. All presented in stunning visual quality with enhanced performance, this is the world of Boletaria as you have never seen it before..
  • Become the Slayer of Demons - Venture to the northern kingdom of Boletaria – a once prosperous land of knights, now beset with unspeakable creatures and ravenous demons. Meet strange characters, unhinged and twisted by the world around them, and unravel the unsettling story of Demon’s Souls..
  • Face the world’s greatest warriors in ferocious PVP combat - With online invasions adding to the danger of your quest. Or play cooperatively by summoning allies to aid in your fight against the demons. Active PS Plus subscription required for online multiplayer..
Check Stock

Shadowshaper The Shadowshaper Cypher Book 1

  • The Medium is a third-person psychological horror game that features patented dual-reality gameplay and an original soundtrack co-composed by....
  • Use your psychic abilities to solve puzzles spanning both worlds, uncover deeply disturbing secrets, and survive encounters with the Maw - a monster....
  • Delve into a mature and morally ambiguous story, where nothing is what it seems - with every new perspective you will change your perception on what....
  • The Medium's spirit world is a dark mirror reflection of our reality, a grim and unsettling place where our unpunished deeds, evil urges, and vile....
  • Explore the physical world and the spirit world simultaneously, and use the interactions between them to solve dual-reality puzzles, unlock new paths,....
Check Stock

Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - Foul Play & Cabernet, Red

  • Foul play and Cabernet isn't just another jigsaw puzzle it's a murder mystery waiting to be solved.
  • First, read about the mystery at the Bloomfield winery.
  • Next, assemble the puzzle and uncover hidden clues to solve the mystery.
  • Completed 1000-Piece puzzle measures 23'' X 29'', for puzzlers 15 and over.
  • Completed 1000-Piece puzzle measures 23'' X 29''.
  • Bepuzzled is more than just jigsaw puzzles - it's puzzle-plus.
  • Foul Play and Cabernet isn't just another jigsaw puzzle it's a murder mystery waiting to be solved.
  • First, read about the mystery at the BloomField Winery.
  • Completed 1000-piece puzzle measures 23'' x 29''.
  • BePuzzled is more than just jigsaw puzzles - it's puzzle-plus.
Check Stock

Dive Bar

  • Solve a Murder of a Small-Town Bar Owner: Death at the Dive Bar is an immersive puzzle game solving the death of local bar owner Nick Webster.
  • Mystery Game to Solve an Unsolved Case: Work solo or with friends or family as you solve the mystery.
  • 1/5 difficulty for puzzle game beginners.
  • Mystery Boxes for Game Night: Hunt a Killer is perfect for game night or a murder mystery party.
  • our mystery game box has everything for an adult game night.
  • Fun Family Puzzle Game: Enjoy 45-60 minutes investigating the murder at the dive bar and become part of a thrilling crime game experience with 1-5 players.
  • Immersive Mystery & Crime Games: Change up game night with Hunt A Killer games.
  • story-driven card, puzzle, and board games that will challenge your problem-solving skills.
Check Stock

Lipglass Dive Bar

  • Solve a Murder of a Small-Town Bar Owner: Death at the Dive Bar is an immersive puzzle game solving the death of local bar owner Nick Webster.
  • Mystery Game to Solve an Unsolved Case: Work solo or with friends or family as you solve the mystery.
  • 1/5 difficulty for puzzle game beginners.
  • Mystery Boxes for Game Night: Hunt a Killer is perfect for game night or a murder mystery party.
  • our mystery game box has everything for an adult game night.
  • Fun Family Puzzle Game: Enjoy 45-60 minutes investigating the murder at the dive bar and become part of a thrilling crime game experience with 1-5 players.
  • Immersive Mystery & Crime Games: Change up game night with Hunt A Killer games.
  • story-driven card, puzzle, and board games that will challenge your problem-solving skills.
Check Stock

Dive Bar [Explicit]

  • Solve a Murder of a Small-Town Bar Owner: Death at the Dive Bar is an immersive puzzle game solving the death of local bar owner Nick Webster.
  • Mystery Game to Solve an Unsolved Case: Work solo or with friends or family as you solve the mystery.
  • 1/5 difficulty for puzzle game beginners.
  • Mystery Boxes for Game Night: Hunt a Killer is perfect for game night or a murder mystery party.
  • our mystery game box has everything for an adult game night.
  • Fun Family Puzzle Game: Enjoy 45-60 minutes investigating the murder at the dive bar and become part of a thrilling crime game experience with 1-5 players.
  • Immersive Mystery & Crime Games: Change up game night with Hunt A Killer games.
  • story-driven card, puzzle, and board games that will challenge your problem-solving skills.
Check Stock

The Dive Bars

  • Solve a Murder of a Small-Town Bar Owner: Death at the Dive Bar is an immersive puzzle game solving the death of local bar owner Nick Webster.
  • Mystery Game to Solve an Unsolved Case: Work solo or with friends or family as you solve the mystery.
  • 1/5 difficulty for puzzle game beginners.
  • Mystery Boxes for Game Night: Hunt a Killer is perfect for game night or a murder mystery party.
  • our mystery game box has everything for an adult game night.
  • Fun Family Puzzle Game: Enjoy 45-60 minutes investigating the murder at the dive bar and become part of a thrilling crime game experience with 1-5 players.
  • Immersive Mystery & Crime Games: Change up game night with Hunt A Killer games.
  • story-driven card, puzzle, and board games that will challenge your problem-solving skills.
Check Stock

PJ Masks Mystery Mountain Playset

  • The PJ Masks are traveling to mystery Mountain! The new PJ Masks mystery Mountain Playset is full of kid powered play! Climb up the mountain on the....
  • Mystery Mountain Playset includes: mystery Mountain Playset, one lava ball, 3” catboy figure, and 3” night Ninja figure.
  • Use the lava elevator to climb to the top of mystery Mountain.
  • Use the trap door to escape from the Dragon hiding behind the Pagoda gate.
Check Stock

Mystery Gift Bags, Blind Bag Party Favors, Surprise Drawstring Goody Bags - Red CA2500Mystery S2

  • USA PRINTS- All Mato & Hash Mystery Grab Bags are printed and designed right here in the United States..
  • TOP SECRET- Mystery Gift bags are made from 100% Polyester and are a prefect Blind Bag for your next event or Party. Ripstop Nylon hides the gifts inside and everyone will be surprised when they open their gift bag and see the favors inside. Also great for storing/hiding clues for Mystery Parties..
  • SHHH!- Mato & Hash Mystery Goody Bags measure 15.5” X 13.5” and are the perfect Drawstring Bags for Murder Mystery Parties, Mystery Give always at promotional events, or Secret gift bags for your next Birthday Party!.
  • BULK- As always Mato & Hash provides the highest quality Drawstring Bags at unbeatable prices! We offer our Mystery Blind Bags in bulk packs of 1,3,6, and 10 Pack options. No need to break the bank when thanking your guest, we have got you covered..
Check Stock

Remothered: Broken Porcelain (NSW) - Nintendo Switch

  • Thrilling Plot - The award-winning cult classic Remothered returns in Broken Porcelain, perfect for new fans as well as series veterans craving additional lore surrounding Tormented Fathers.
  • Realistic Survival Horror – Scour the environment for items to aid your exploration of unsettling locations that hide grave secrets of a terrifying past.
  • Intense Stealth Gameplay - Roam among the shadows of Ashmann Inn and use everything at your disposal to distract enemies for a resourceful escape.
  • Investigate and Escape - Challenging puzzles, expanded lore, and a haunting soundtrack transforms the dark and gloomy atmosphere into a terrifying experience haunting players well after the game is over.
  • Captivating Characters - The roster of charismatic characters grows as fan favorites return to meet all the new additions to the cast inspired by the protagonists of horror classics.
Check Stock

The Bible: The Epic Miniseries

  • Zuru 5 Surprise Mini Brands Series 3 Mystery Case - Surprise Mini Food Toys Mystery Set with Shopkins Stickers and More (Collectible Food Toys Bundle)..
  • This mystery Mini Brands bundle comes with one Mini Brands mystery case including 4 exclusive Mini Brands toys featuring favorite snacks and treats..
  • Sure to be a hit with kids of all ages, these Mini Brands mystery case is great to use as party favors, party supplies, goodie bag fillers, gift basket fillers, and more!.
  • With over 70 different mini food toy figures to collect, these 4 Surprise Series 3 Mini Brands cases are fun for everyone! Enjoy the mystery of opening the case to see which miniature toy versions of tasty treats you got!.
  • Officially licensed Zuru 5 Surprise Mini Brands are great for kids and adults, boys and girls alike, and also comes with Shopkins stickers and a Luna and the Cloud Elves door hanger..
Check Stock

Mystery Gift Bags, Mini Blind Bag Party Favors, Surprise Drawstring Goody Bags - 6PK Royal CA2655Mystery S5

  • USA PRINTS- All Mato & Hash Mystery Grab Bags are printed and designed right here in the United States..
  • TOP SECRET- Mystery Gift bags are made from 100% Ripstop Nylon and are a prefect Blind Bag for your next event or Party. Ripstop Nylon hides the gifts inside and everyone will be surprised when they open their gift bag and see the favors inside. Also great for storing/hiding clues for Mystery Parties..
  • SHHH!- Mato & Hash Mystery Goody Bags measure 12” X 10” and are the perfect Drawstring Bags for Murder Mystery Parties, Mystery Give always at promotional events, or Secret gift bags for your next Birthday Party!.
  • BULK- As always Mato & Hash provides the highest quality Drawstring Bags at unbeatable prices! We offer our Mystery Blind Bags in bulk packs of 1,3,6, and 10 Pack options. No need to break the bank when thanking your guest, we have got you covered..
Check Stock

Remothered: Broken Porcelain (PS4) - PlayStation 4

  • Thrilling Plot - The award-winning cult classic Remothered returns in Broken Porcelain, perfect for new fans as well as series veterans craving additional lore surrounding Tormented Fathers.
  • Realistic Survival Horror – Scour the environment for items to aid your exploration of unsettling locations that hide grave secrets of a terrifying past.
  • Intense Stealth Gameplay - Roam among the shadows of Ashmann Inn and use everything at your disposal to distract enemies for a resourceful escape.
  • Investigate and Escape - Challenging puzzles, expanded lore, and a haunting soundtrack transforms the dark and gloomy atmosphere into a terrifying experience haunting players well after the game is over.
  • Captivating Characters - The roster of charismatic characters grows as fan favorites return to meet all the new additions to the cast inspired by the protagonists of horror classics.
Check Stock